by Nick Gromicko, CMI® and Ben Gromicko
This article explains the issues and concerns with conventional ventilated crawlspaces and outlines prescriptive measures for improvements that will create healthier and more durable spaces. This information is provided by the U.S. Department of Energy Building Technologies Office Building America Program "Guide to Closing and Conditioning Ventilated Crawlspaces."
Home inspectors should use this how-to guide as a tool to help them perform inspections of crawlspaces, identify indications of defects associated with crawlspaces, and properly recommend strategies to convert a traditional crawlspace with open foundation vents, and poor design and construction into an unvented, insulated, and conditioned space.
This article is intended to apply to crawlspace foundations that are constructed of solid concrete or concrete masonry units (CMUs) with a continuous brick cap or bond beam that minimizes the potential for moisture movement from the ground through the masonry cores toward the wood floor structure (see Figure 1).
Figure 1. Types of crawlspace foundation systems applicable to this article.
The methods described here are not the only acceptable ways to treat a crawlspace but represent a proven strategy that works in many areas of the United States. The designs discussed here may or may not meet the local building codes.
Crawlspaces in the United States typically are constructed of hollow masonry block or poured concrete stem walls. In general, these foundations are equipped with permanent vents to the outdoors that are intended to furnish cross-ventilation to prevent moisture in the space. Until recently, houses built over vented crawlspaces have been constructed with little or no regard to moisture-causing sources that can contribute to long-term structural damage and pose health hazards. The interior and exterior detailing of many construction components needs to be evaluated and installed correctly to combat unwanted moisture within a crawlspace. Past research has shown that a conventionally vented crawlspace that has been converted into an unvented and conditioned space tends to operate similarly to houses with basements, with several benefits for the homeowner (BSC 2004), including:
Research has shown that vented crawlspaces located in mixed or hot-humid climates tend to increase the moisture level within the space instead of keeping it drier. This increased moisture then condenses on the colder wood surfaces of the floor framing, promoting fungal growth and wood damage. Vented crawlspaces also have the potential to rob energy savings from the living spaces of the home if the appropriate insulation strategy has not been followed correctly. Retrofitting a vented crawlspace into an unvented, insulated, sealed and dry space requires more than just sealing off the vent openings. Not considering other details within the crawlspace and simply sealing the vents could make the situation worse, increasing the levels of moisture and potentially creating a deadly situation if naturally ventilated types of combustion equipment are located in the crawlspace. Depending on the conditions, it might be best to implement the closed-crawlspace strategy slowly to minimize the effects of materials rapidly drying out. Rapid and excessive drying can potentially cause cosmetic damage to wood-based finish products in the living area of the home. Conversely, swollen and cupped hardwood flooring may flatten during the drying process.
Basic Concepts: Moisture Transport
Where Does the Moisture in a Crawlspace Come From?
There are four primary modes of moisture migration into a home: capillary action; bulk moisture transport; air transport; and vapor diffusion. Each of these modes, described in the following list, must be controlled to preserve comfort, health, and building durability.
Use a backflow valve in crawlspace drains and a check valve in sump pump out-flow pipes to prevent reverse flow of outside water into the crawlspace and to reduce the chance of vermin entry. Floor drains with P-traps that connect to the whole-house plumbing waste drain or to a municipal sewer system may allow entry or sewer gases if or when the trap dries out and pose a risk of sewage backup.
Other Contaminants
Feces, Carcasses, and Other Animal Waste
Old existing crawlspaces, if left unattended, can contain large amounts of animal droppings or carcasses of animals that have found a way into the crawlspace and died. Be prepared for this possibility. If these contaminants are found, a thorough cleanup must be conducted before proceeding.
Animal Infestation
In some cases, crawlspaces that have been left unattended or neglected can harbor wild animals. Recognizing the exterior details that allow entry and exit and other activity will help prepare the inspector. Depending on the severity, the local animal control agency might need to assist in removing any unwanted animals.
Pest Control
Termites and carpenter ants are known to thrive in dark, damp places that have a readily available food source nearby. Inspecting the foundation walls and framing for signs of wood-destroying organisms is required before proceeding. Any observed indications of infestation will then require a more in-depth inspection and treatment by a pest control professional.
Thermal Issues
Insulation Strategy
The current insulation levels, location and integrity will need to be assessed to determine the appropriate strategy for the climatic region. Any existing fiberglass batt insulation in the floor system or draped over the foundation walls should be removed and discarded. A good work plan will include a thorough specification and implementation strategy for thermal insulation.
Space Conditioning
Crawlspaces must always have a drying mechanism. One of the most effective ways is to condition the crawlspace is by bringing in a reduced amount of conditioned air from the mechanical system to temper the space as if it were part of the home. A supply- and return-air strategy must be included to semi-condition the crawlspace.
In some areas of the country that do not have air conditioning, or if local requirements will not allow band joist insulation, it might be necessary to install a permanent dehumidification system in the crawlspace to maintain the 30%–50% humidity levels within the space.
Table 1 summarizes the conditions that will necessitate stopping all work on the crawlspace project. Once these problems have been solved, renovation work can resume.
Table 1. Critical Checklist
When to Stop Work and Not Proceed | |
If any mold or wood rot is observed during the initial inspection, then… | A mold assessment professional will have to conduct an in-depth inspection and follow up with the proper remediation of the affected areas. No work can proceed until the space has been certified clean by the mold professional. Any rotten structural wood material must be removed and replaced. |
If there are questionable electrical practices or any exposed wiring that poses a safety threat, then… | A qualified electrician will have to conduct a thorough inspection of all wiring within the crawlspace and make necessary corrections to meet current code requirements. |
If the house has natural draft combustion appliances (furnace, water heater) located in the crawlspace, then… | A qualified HVAC technician will have to conduct an analysis of the combustion makeup air strategy. The best practice would be to remove and replace all naturally vented appliances with direct-vent (two-pipe) models to ensure adequate combustion air and sealed exhausting when fuel-fired appliances are used. |
If recognizable signs of termite or other pest-related activity or damage are observed, then… | A certified pest inspector will have to perform an inspection and apply treatment, if necessary, before renovation work can proceed. |
If standing water is observed anywhere on the crawlspace floor, then… | The standing water will have to be removed, and the source of the water will have to be determined and eliminated. |
If measured radon levels exceed the EPA's acceptable levels, then… | A radon mitigation professional will have to develop an appropriate strategy to be implemented. |
Figure 6. Water management to keep bulk water away from the crawlspace
Crawlspace Access
The general location and overall weather seal of the access door must be inspected. The access door (Figure 7) must be a minimum of 6 inches above the exterior grade to prevent runoff or snowmelt from entering. The door needs to be made of a non-corroding material, and the opening must be weatherstripped to prevent moisture and air from entering the space. Once all detailing is completed, a lock should be installed on the door.
702.1 All air from indoors. Combustion and dilution air shall be permitted to be obtained entirely from the indoors in buildings that are not of unusually tight construction. In buildings of unusually tight construction, combustion air shall be obtained from the outdoors in accordance with Section 703, 705, 706 or 707.
702.2 Air from the same room or space. The room or space containing fuel-burning appliances shall be in unconfined space as defined in Section 202.
702.3 Air from adjacent spaces. Where the volume of the room in which the fuel-burning appliances are located does not comply with Section 702.2, additional inside combustion and dilution air shall be obtained by opening the room to adjacent spaces so that the combined volume of all communicating spaces meets the volumetric requirement of Section 702.2. Openings connecting the spaces shall comply with Sections 702.3.1 and 702.3.2.
702.3.1 Number and location of openings. Two openings shall be provided, one within 1 foot of the ceiling of the room, and one within 1 foot of the floor.
702.3.2 Size of openings. The net free area of each opening, calculated in accordance with Section 708, shall be a minimum of 1 square inch per 1,000 BTU/h of input rating of the fuel-burning appliances drawing combustion and dilution air from the communicating spaces and shall not be less than 100 square inches.
Figure 11. Direct vent furnace with combustion air intake and exhaust pipes directly to outdoors
In crawlspaces with combustion-type appliances, NFPA 720 requirements dictate installing a carbon monoxide alarm (NPFA 2012). Depressurization tests should be conducted if natural vented equipment (B-vent) is installed. These tests measure the pressure of the crawlspace in relation to the house and in relation to the outdoors. If the crawlspace is reading negative to the house or to the outdoors, it will be necessary to make adjustments to correct the imbalance. A negative reading indicates that the passive return might be too large or that the sealing on the return ductwork is unsatisfactory.
Ductwork
Visually inspect all ductwork located within the crawlspace, making sure the joints and connections are well-sealed. It is more important to pay attention to the sealing on the return-air ducts than the supply ducts because any supply leaks are adding conditioned air to the crawlspace, helping to condition the space. Sealing return leaks is more critical to minimize the potential for back-drafting of atmospherically vented equipment within the crawlspace. If the duct system is wrapped with insulation and the insulation is in good condition, a duct leakage test is recommended to determine the extent of system leakage. Depending on the amount of leakage, it may be necessary to remove the insulation to seal the ducts. In addition to air sealing, inspect the supports for all flexible ductwork. Strapping the flexible duct at 3-foot intervals will eliminate sagging and increase the air-delivery performance of the system (see Figure 12).
Figure 12. Seal and support duct system
Space Conditioning
Cost-effective ways to semi-condition the crawlspace and maintain a dry environment include making sure that the air handler furnishes the proper amount of conditioned supply air (Figure
13) and implementing a passive return strategy (Figure 14) to the living space. At a minimum, air should be delivered at a rate equal to 1 cfm for each 50 square feet of under-floor area, or 50 cfm total, whichever is greater. This strategy meets the requirements of the 2009
International Residential Code, Section R408.3 (IRC 2009b, p. 108); however, local codes may have different requirements.
Air-Conditioning Condensate Drainage
Make sure the condensate drain is routed, per local jurisdiction requirements, directly to a sealed drain point, such as a sealed sump crock lid, floor drain fitting, or the sanitary sewer system. In addition to the primary drain, and as a safety precaution if the primary drain fails, install an auxiliary drain pan with a separate drain beneath any cooling or evaporator coil to prevent any accidental spillage of condensate onto the crawlspace floor.
Dehumidifiers
Air-conditioning systems are not typically used in some mild- and cold-climate areas of the United States. In these conditions, it might be necessary to install a dehumidifier that is tied into a sealed drain point.
Figure 13. Supply air diffuser
Figure 14. Underside of passive vent in floor structure
Band Joist Insulation
Take extreme precautions when insulating band joist areas. The installer must assess the moisture potential of both the interior and exterior conditions where the mudsill, band joist and floor system all meet at the top of the crawlspace walls. If, in the installer’s judgment, the installation of insulation will not cause high moisture content in the wood and long-term rot, insulate this area. If there is any question about the drying potential at this area, the safest practice would be not to insulate and to allow free drying of the wood materials (Figure 15).
It is up to the contractor to determine the best order in which to seal the band joist and the vent opening sealing in relation to the vapor barrier installation.
If it has been determined that there is no risk of moisture at the band joist area, the following methods are recommended to air seal and insulate the band joist area:
Figure 17. Measure existing foundation vent openings.
Figure 18. Cut rigid foam inserts to fit over the existing foundation vents.
Figure 19. Use spray foam to seal the edges of the foam inserts.
Crawlspace Floor
Poly Vapor Barrier
The floor of the crawlspace is a critical factor in eliminating moisture movement from the soil into the crawlspace environment. Improper installation of the vapor barrier will allow ground moisture to infiltrate the crawlspace and raise the relative humidity. Implementing a comprehensive vapor barrier strategy on the crawlspace floor is one of the most important tasks to carry out. For it to be successful, pay close attention to details.
Figure 20. Clean and grade the crawlspace.
Figure 21. Lap the vapor barrier and seal the connection.
Figure 22. Apply poly vapor barrier and lap and seal the seams.
Figure 23. Use mesh tape to seal the vapor barrier to the interior surface of the foundation walls
4 inches below the top of the wall.
Figure 24. Embed the mesh tape with mastic to complete the seal.
Sump Pump Crock Pit and Floor Drain
Sump pump pits can contribute large amounts of moisture to the crawlspace if not detailed correctly. The lids to the crock pits are often missing, unattached, or sealed incorrectly. To eliminate this potential moisture source, make sure crock pits have well-sealed lids that fit tightly. If a sealable lid is not available, replace the entire unit. Once a sealed unit is installed, seal the vapor barrier on the crawlspace floor to the sump crock along the perimeter (Figure 25).
If a low-point floor drain has been installed, ensure that the perimeter of the drain is sealed to the vapor barrier (Figure 26).
Figure 25. Crock pit lid sealing
Figure 26. Low-point floor drain sealing
Wall Insulation
The 2009 International Energy Conservation Code prescriptive requirements for insulation levels for crawlspace walls (IECC 2009, p. 27, Table 402.1.1) are as follows:
Figure 28. Install rigid insulation to the crawlspace walls, allowing a 3-inch termite strip, if needed.
Figure 29. Vent area insulation
Figure 30. Vent area sealing
Final Steps
Service Areas
Consider installing an additional protection layer (e.g., indoor/outdoor carpet runners, carpet protection mats) at the crawlspace entry and traffic areas to the mechanical equipment. This additional protection will help maintain the integrity of the vapor barrier. Additional convenience items to consider installing or having as a kit at the entrance are lighting, knee pads, dust masks, and a broom for sweeping cobwebs.
Water-Sensing Alarm
The installation of a water-leak alarm at a low spot or near the drain in the crawlspace is a good practice. These alarms alert the homeowners of potential pipe leaks or other unwanted water on the crawlspace floor that otherwise may go undetected for long periods of time.
Vapor Barrier Inspection
As the last step in the crawlspace project, a final inspection of the vapor barrier should be conducted following all repair activities. Any tears or rips in the vapor barrier that may have occurred during other repairs must be sealed before the job can be deemed completed.
Additional Monitoring Equipment
As an option, consider installing a humidistat that allows the homeowner to track the performance of the crawlspace and to detect irregular moisture loading.
Figure 31. Details of a complete interior crawlspace
Homeowner Education
Warning Sign
Post a warning sign at the entrance to the crawlspace about the system components and the importance of maintaining system integrity (Figure 32).
Figure 32. Example of a warning sign posted at an access entryway